DIY Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies

How to Make Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies for Valentine's Day

How to Make Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies for Valentine's Day

How to Make Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies for Valentine's Day

We had so much fun at Christmas with our Elf Quote sugar cookies that we had to do it again! I figured Valentine’s Day would be the perfect opportunity to get wordy on some heart-shaped cookies, so these Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies were born! I went a little hog wild making up phrases or putting our favorite lyrics on them…

How to Make Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies for Valentine's Day

And just in case Valentine’s Day isn’t your thing, we made a few cranky ones. Because “Bye Felicia” should definitely be on a conversation heart somewhere in the world.

How to Make Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies for Valentine's Day

If you want to make these bad boys, follow our tutorial for our Elf Quote cookies! Be sure to read it thoroughly – there are lots of tips and tricks for getting the cookies just right. It’s the exact same process with the exact same materials. If you’d like to replicate our colors, use the food coloring on that ingredients list and separate the dough into quarters. We colored each quarter differently with these drop amounts:

  • pale pink = 1 drop pink
  • bright pink = 6 drops pink
  • lavender = 4 drops purple
  • blue = 1 drop green, 4 drops blue

Then go to town with your cookie imprinting set and make them say whatever you want! This would actually be a super fun thing to do at a Valentine’s (or Galentine’s!) party. You could do it with kids, too — set up the cookies and let them stamp words to their hearts’ content.

Hope you try some of these bad boys! If you do, share ’em on Instagram with #thelovelysquad so we can see whether you love or hate Valentine’s Day. Ha! xoxo

How to Make Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies for Valentine's Day

How to Make Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies for Valentine's Day

How to Make Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies for Valentine's Day

Photos by Scot Woodman

  1. Pingback: Weekly Link Love - The Sweetest Occasion — The Sweetest Occasion

  2. I LOVE THE MEAN ONES!!!!! Especially “hard pass”. Yes yes yes. I have a necklace with mean conversation hearts and the one that says “Can U Not” is my fave. So great!

  3. We are always looking former ways to enjoy a healthy breakfast and thus looks delicious! What a creative way to eat quinoa!cant wait ty try!

  4. brittni on said:

    Love these Chelsea! And the photos look fantastic.

  5. amy c on said:

    Fab! Aw hell no is my favorite too.

  6. Very positive and beautiful post! I really like your style! You love simple and cute things, and you can make your readers feel happy and joyful. Thanks:) Have a wonderful day!

  7. Pingback: Oreo Cookie Milkshake

  8. Pingback: Extreme Valentine's Day Roundup - Design Crush

  9. Pingback: handmade savvy saturday - the handmade home

  10. Pingback: DIY Tic-Tac-Toe Valentine with X and O Cookies » Lovely Indeed

  11. Pingback: Make Seriously Yummy Valentine Treats for Kids

  12. Pingback: 6 DIYs You Can Do Before Valentine's Day » Lovely Indeed

  13. Pingback: friday, i’m in love

  14. Pingback: BASH

  15. Pingback: DIY Valentine's Day Roundup | A Kiss of Colour

  16. Pingback: Love is In The Air With These 50 DIY Valentine's Day Ideas • Cool Crafts

  17. Pingback: 8 Favorite DIYs for Valentine’s Day |

  18. Pingback: 50 VALENTINES DAY CAKES BAKES DESSERTS PUDDINGS & SWEET SNACKS | Bespoke-Bride: Wedding Blog

*