When my sister, my cousins, and I were little these cookies were all we wanted during Christmas at Grammie’s house. She would bake a whole bunch and let us frost and decorate them (I would always load mine up with sugar crystals like it was my last day on Earth). They’re not like a traditional sugar cookie — they’re a little less sweet because of the honey in the recipe. But they taste to me like being a kid at Christmas, and they’re a perfect project if you have little ones around who’d like to help out. So if you wanna try Grammie’s Merry Christmas Cookies, follow along!
1/3 c soft Crisco
1/3 c sugar
1/2 c honey
1/4 c butter (room temp)
1 t vanilla flavor
2 ¾ c flour
1 t baking soda
1 t salt
Mix shortening, sugar, egg, honey, butter, and vanilla thoroughly. Blend flour, soda, and salt, and stir into shortening mixture. Once well mixed, refrigerate until cool. Remove from refrigerator and knead with your hands until the dough is soft enough to roll out smoothly and without cracking. Roll to about 1/4″ thick. Use cookie cutters to cut out shapes.
Put shapes on a piece of parchment paper and place on a baking sheet. Bake approximately 8 minutes at 350 degrees. Keep a close eye on them, though, as oven temperatures vary and these bake very quickly. I like to take mine out just before they begin to brown. Makes about 4 dozen cookies, depending on the size of your cookie cutters.
1/4 c milk
2 1/4 c powdered sugar
Mix milk and sugar and whisk gently until the mixture becomes thick. Separate into a few containers and use food coloring if desired. Gently smooth icing onto cookies using a knife, spoon, or spatula. (Add decorations if you’re feeling festive!)
Mr. Lovely made the comment that these are cookies that get better with age, and I agree! I love them the day after they’re made, when the icing and the cookie have a little chance to rest and get more delicious. Oh, and if you’re wondering, the forest animal cookie cutters came from IKEA. (There’s a moose, fox, bear, snail, porcupine, and squirrel. So cute.) Have fun! xoxo
21 thoughts on “Family Recipes // Merry Christmas Cookies”
These are darling! Love that squirrel cookie! Such a fun cookie collection! 🙂
Thanks Gracie! The squirrel and the moose are definitely my favorite.
i love your biscuit cutters <3
Thanks Caroline! They were a total steal too, a really good bargain at Ikea.
Thanks Sara! Hope you try them out.
Love!!! I happen to agree that frosting gets better with age. Like a fine wine. Except wine doesn’t get crunchy and delicious…
Haha! Eeewwww what if wine got crunchy?
When I was apartment shopping a couple years ago I saw one lived in by some very untidy girls and I think there was some crunchy wine on a countertop…
Okay, well these are adorable! I have these cookie cutters too, so I could totally make some.
Thanks B! I just about lost it when I saw them at Ikea.
This is the first I have seen of these pretty shapes. How sweet.
Do you still have the ones hiding in the pantry? 😉
Cutest ever! Love these little woodland cookies.
Thanks Leah! I may or may not have eaten approximately 7 of those squirrels. 😉
I love these! That little squirrel is adorable, I would literally eat him all up.
So cute…and your nails look awesome! I want a moose cookie! 🙂
I absolutely ADORE the shape of these cookies, and they sound like such a delightful holiday treat! Where in the world did you find those cookie cutters?